Sunday, January 22, 2012


Cookies, Chocolate and Peanut Butter! Can't think of anything much better than that.  This recipe comes from Laura who's blog is  Real Mom Kitchen.  She visits a cookie shop called Over the Top Cookies, in Utah.  They take regular cookies and cover them with other yummy stuff.  Laura likes their Peanut Butter Cup Collision and went home and came up with her home made version.  Good job.  These cookies are over the top.  It would be difficult to eat just one.  Laura suggest they are best eaten on the same day or the next.  I wouldn't know, they were sent to CB K with Mr. Dick.   Gone!  But a big thank you to Laura for another wonderful cookie recipe.     Happy baking everyone.          Andi  

3/4 cup butter, softened
1 cup sugar
1 cup brown sugar
2 large eggs
2 tsp vanilla
1 tsp baking soda
1/2 tsp salt
2 1/2 cups flour
*1 1/2 cups milk chocolate chips
32 mini Reese's Peanut Butter cups, each cut in 4 pieces

Using your stand mixer, add the softened butter, along with the sugars and blend until light and fluffy. Add eggs one at a time along with the vanilla. Mix well.

In another bowl add the dry ingredients and whisk together to combine.

Add the dry ingredients slowly to the creamed butter mixture. Stir in the chips.

Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Prepare your baking sheets with parchment paper. Scoop out the size cookie you want, I use my small ice cream cookie scoop. It holds about 2 Tbsp of dough. I pressed the ball down a little. Bake until almost done, remove from the oven and lightly press about 6-8 pieces of the cut up Reese's into each cookie. Return to the oven for a couple of minutes. The timing will depend on the size of each cookie. Allow to set on the cookie sheet for a little then remove to a cooking rack.

* Variation: you could use M&M's mini or regular in place of the Reese's.

Print Recipe

Shared with   Flour me with Love  cozyhomescenes

crazy for crust   chef-in-training    sugar and dots    raegunwear     made-famous-by  bell miracle


  1. wow look absolutely declicious!

  2. So glad you liked them and love your photo.

  3. Our family loves peanut butter cookies, I'll be making these very soon :)

  4. These sound really wonderful. Love peanut butter cookies! Thanks for sharing. Pat

  5. Oh my goodness! Those cookies look wonderful!

  6. I love the way you re-used the milk carton! Great idea!

  7. These look and sound extremely sinful and delicious!!

  8. Love the way you have these displayed! The milk box is such a clever idea. Those cookies sound wonderful, especially since I love peanut butter and chocolate anything. Bet I would love them, so next time send some my way. Tee hee!

    Andi, thank you so much for joining my party. I really appreciate your support. Please come back whenever you can because I love seeing what you have to share!

  9. OM NOM NOM!! They look great-and I'm a huge Reese lover so...yeah...this is awesome lol.

  10. I would love for you to add this recipe to my Famous Linkz Party!! I have one every Wednesday.

  11. Looks Yummy! I am your newest follower ! Please post these at my party http://bell

  12. This recipe looks so good! The men in my life love PB cookies! I can't wait to make it for them! I'm having a linky party as well, and would love for you to join it! Here is the link Thanks for sharing!

  13. Thank you for sharing these scrumptious cookies at Mix it up Monday, I hope to see you next week too!

  14. Found you through Sugar & Dots linky party :)
    I am pinning this recipe so that I can make it one of these days.

  15. wowzer! these cookies...and the packaging...ADORABLE! really, just sayin'!